Fast broken blog or working one? you choose


I just got another ticket off someone that is using a cache plugin and experiencing issues with a plugin.

BTW – Do you recommend NOT using W3TC? And, if so, is there a better one?

Here’s my response, maybe if you read it here then I wont have to type it again in a ticket!

oh that is a biggie! w3 total cache by definition will serve old copies of pages. That is what all cache plugins are designed to do.

it is quicker to serve a html copy than to generate one with php which is why they make sites faster.

unfortunately, blogs are dynamic sites with plugins that require freshly created content which don’t really work well with copies of pages that were made hours or even days ago.

static business sites that are there for information work really well with cache plugins because they rarely change but blogs with new posts and comments and ‘real time’ plugins installed don’t do so well.

w3 total cache is not yet final. That is why it is not showing as version 1.0 yet. You and me and all the others that use it are test subjects!

you have to decide if you want a fast broken blog or a working one.

there are blogs (including mine) that have w3 working with everything else but each blog is different and has different plugins active so you will have to find your own set of settings that works for you.

unforunately, w3 is the best (or the least bad) of the cache plugins but like I said, cache plugins are designed to serve old content and blogs are designed to serve fresh content. that’s the issue that comes up again and again with any cache plugin and a blog.

sorry I can’t help more but w3 is a beast of a plugin and the author keeps changing the core code so I can’t add things to commentluv to work with it, the last time I tried it worked but as soon as he updated his code it broke every commentluv blog so I don’t try any more.

the best advice I can give is to optimize your site first before considering a cache plugin, you’d be surprised at how much that can help.

and if you do decide on a cache plugin, test test test!

The takeaways…
  • If you do not know what a cache plugin does then you do not need one!
  • If you have a slow broken site, a cache plugin will not fix it!
  • If minifying breaks one script, it breaks them all!
  • Scripts that are already minified (jquery.min.js) do not need to be minified!
  • You should optimize your site before you try to speed it up with cache plugins!
  • test test test .. experiment with settings to see what gets you a working site and then test test test again!
  • Switching every option to MAX and then expecting it just to work is not really gonna happen on shared hosting with a free theme and a bazillion free plugins.

Blog News, Code

17 Comments zu “Fast broken blog or working one? you choose”

  1. Jackson Tate
    22.04.12 3:24 am

    I’ve had to disable W3TC on a few sites b/c of the way it messes with cookies. One tip, especially for those on shared hosting: try WP Super Cache. It’s less complex and has less options to gunk up your site.
    Jackson Tate recently posted..How to Become a Professional Tax PreparerMy Profile


  2. tokoonline
    25.04.12 10:08 pm

    the irony of WordPress plugin – there no consensus. but if you want something free, you got free. need more ? buy support ;)
    tokoonline recently posted..Index of online Store – Konsultan Toko OnlineMy Profile


  3. Jacob
    26.04.12 11:41 am

    Personally I now only use Quick Cache on my blogs and find it to be very user friendly (only need to turn it on once installed)… and it seems to be working just fine when I do speed tests… that is my recommendation :)
    Jacob recently posted..Revitol Rosacea Treatment CreamMy Profile


  4. Mel Quincy
    02.05.12 7:26 pm

    This post is quite valuable and it has helped me in some ways. What cache plugin do you recommend the most? Thanks a lot for the info Andy!
    Mel Quincy recently posted..Click thisMy Profile


  5. Chuck
    06.05.12 10:06 pm

    I personally would want a blog that works. It may seem like taking the quick and easy way might be the way to go but if you don’t want a headache take your time and do it right the first time.


  6. max
    11.05.12 11:40 pm

    i migh tbe wrong but i think the secret ingrediant is putting out good quality blogs everytime with great content, the hurdle is getting over that lovely writers block when it rears its ugly head


  7. Beth
    18.05.12 9:37 pm

    Hi Andy, I’ve had mixed results using cache plugins to the point where I try and avoid them. I know some hosts insist on you installing a cache plugin if your website is using a lot of resources. Compatibility with other plugins can be a problem, as you mention in your post.
    Beth recently posted..How To Get a Boyfriend BackMy Profile


  8. Chuck
    21.05.12 3:33 pm

    I think it really depends on the size of your blog as well as the amount of things you have loading on your site. If you have a fairly small blog without a ton of images and or ads you shouldn’t need a cache.


  9. Jeneatte
    28.05.12 7:56 am

    There’s nothing wrong to try and test what suit t your site. Some plugin doesn’t much with the other. It depends on how big or small your site is.
    Jeneatte recently posted..Kensington Windshield Car Mount reviewMy Profile


  10. Ari Wahyudi
    14.06.12 5:45 am

    I am not aware about problems in W3 plugin until one of my readers ask me why I havent updated my blog for a while. And it turned out that my last few posts is not served out. I uninstalled W3 and the problem is gone.

    Too bad, my blog was faster back then.


  11. chapman
    23.06.12 5:28 am

    I have to remove some of my plugins. It slowed down the performance of my site.
    chapman recently posted..Buy Gold and Silver with GoldSilver.comMy Profile


  12. Andre Fernandes
    28.06.12 4:42 am

    Cache plugin will really help load the site faster but sometimes it messes with other plugins, so we need to remove it. The only way to handle this is to test which version of cache plugin that will not messes with other and will work efficiently as expected.
    Andre Fernandes recently posted..Ace Pro Drain CleanerMy Profile


  13. Andre Fernandes
    28.06.12 11:14 am

    I agree good quality blog is the way to go but when your site takes time to load then search engine might not favor your blog. You need to find a way to speed up the loading process. This is where the cache plugin is needed.
    Andre Fernandes recently posted..Ace Pro Drain CleanerMy Profile


  14. Chuck
    28.06.12 3:11 pm

    Well I have had a broken site and i would much rather choose the working one over the broken one


  15. Derek Maak
    03.07.12 7:34 am

    Hey Andy,

    I had to opt for the working blog over a faster broken blog. W3 kept breaking things and I got tired of messing with the settings. I know Google likes a faster site, but it doesn’t do you much good if half the site doesn’t work properly.
    Derek Maak recently posted..What Men Secretly Want • Does Love Or Respect Matter Most?My Profile


  16. Andy
    03.07.12 12:59 pm

    yes that is something I hear a lot of! so many people just install it and expect it to perform miracles with every option turned to max.
    Andy recently posted..Easy 5K with Jeff Galloway reviewMy Profile


  17. babanature
    19.11.12 7:49 pm

    i haven’t used the w3cache plugin before but if i’d choose, i’ll choose the working blog over the fast broken blog.
    babanature recently posted..ACTIVATING WINDOWS 8 WITHOUT USING CRACK OR PATCHMy Profile


Your Comment

CommentLuv badge