Fast broken blog or working one? you choose
April 20, 2012
I just got another ticket off someone that is using a cache plugin and experiencing issues with a plugin.
BTW – Do you recommend NOT using W3TC? And, if so, is there a better one?
Here’s my response, maybe if you read it here then I wont have to type it again in a ticket!
oh that is a biggie! w3 total cache by definition will serve old copies of pages. That is what all cache plugins are designed to do.
it is quicker to serve a html copy than to generate one with php which is why they make sites faster.
unfortunately, blogs are dynamic sites with plugins that require freshly created content which don’t really work well with copies of pages that were made hours or even days ago.
static business sites that are there for information work really well with cache plugins because they rarely change but blogs with new posts and comments and ‘real time’ plugins installed don’t do so well.
w3 total cache is not yet final. That is why it is not showing as version 1.0 yet. You and me and all the others that use it are test subjects!
you have to decide if you want a fast broken blog or a working one.
there are blogs (including mine) that have w3 working with everything else but each blog is different and has different plugins active so you will have to find your own set of settings that works for you.
unforunately, w3 is the best (or the least bad) of the cache plugins but like I said, cache plugins are designed to serve old content and blogs are designed to serve fresh content. that’s the issue that comes up again and again with any cache plugin and a blog.
sorry I can’t help more but w3 is a beast of a plugin and the author keeps changing the core code so I can’t add things to commentluv to work with it, the last time I tried it worked but as soon as he updated his code it broke every commentluv blog so I don’t try any more.
the best advice I can give is to optimize your site first before considering a cache plugin, you’d be surprised at how much that can help.
and if you do decide on a cache plugin, test test test!
- If you do not know what a cache plugin does then you do not need one!
- If you have a slow broken site, a cache plugin will not fix it!
- If minifying breaks one script, it breaks them all!
- Scripts that are already minified (jquery.min.js) do not need to be minified!
- You should optimize your site before you try to speed it up with cache plugins!
- test test test .. experiment with settings to see what gets you a working site and then test test test again!
- Switching every option to MAX and then expecting it just to work is not really gonna happen on shared hosting with a free theme and a bazillion free plugins.